)]}' { "log": [ { "commit": "79b88e0a8cb4dfc9c33fe219045f3da7f64256c4", "tree": "7f2fd3a3fd78b463d001ae7e2f81c70affdd6bfd", "parents": [ "2cfea0076b43001569565c2f625afa42901282cd" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 13:33:09 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 13:33:09 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Limit the juris dead-end claim to what was actually checked\n\nOnly the Schleswig-Holstein and Berlin portals were probed. Stating the\nsame for Baden-Württemberg, Hesse, Thuringia and Lower Saxony would have\ninvited a future session to skip an attempt that might well succeed.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I0fecfff43b4cb941eb973d2c7805a0eee0029781\n" }, { "commit": "2cfea0076b43001569565c2f625afa42901282cd", "tree": "f2dfc99525473ea5af1c02b20521fa9680ae5265", "parents": [ "81777013dfa582053489efea874e84379f1f0805" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 13:32:26 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 13:32:26 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Bring the documentation up to the current state\n\nThe README still described state law as Bavaria-only, six Länder later.\nThe sample-data overview grew a section on how to obtain the pre-\namendment stems per portal — which of the three routes works, and that\nthe juris state portals are a dead end — and a short prioritised \"where\nto continue\", so the next session does not have to re-derive it.\n\nCorrected while writing it: the regression figures are not all pinned\nthe same way. UWG, AGG and ProdHaftG pin \"nothing left manual\", BayJG\npins 154 commands and names its five renumbering residues, and the state\ncases pin full application. Saying \"UWG 19/0, GEG 66/53, …\" would have\ndescribed observations, not what the tests actually assert.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: Ie247e9626e789e628d537bede735923d5b67d14b\n" }, { "commit": "81777013dfa582053489efea874e84379f1f0805", "tree": "83f227c65b91152d4a8aaca67d418da04d601e9e", "parents": [ "c86a73a6e1da7dd28076054936458b850eda2947" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 08:53:10 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 08:53:10 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Support unnumbered named Anlagen; strip control characters\n\nInvestigating \"Anlagen as amendment target\" corrected the diagnosis from\nyesterday: Anlagen are supported. In gii-XML they are norms of their own\n(\"Anlage 8\", \"Anhang\"), Stelle.anlagenEnbez() resolves them, and the GEG\nsample applies annex-targeted commands — only two of its fifty manual\nentries touch annexes, both for content reasons.\n\nWhat actually failed in Berlin was narrower, and is fixed:\n\n * A law with a single annex names it after the provision it belongs to\n (\"Die Anlage zu § 2 Absatz 4 Satz 1\"). StellenParser demanded a\n number after \"Anlage\" and rejected the phrase, so the article\u0027s frame\n command went unrecognised and its items lost their context. The\n annex now carries the designation \"Anlage\", like \"Anhang\". The naming\n suffix is skipped deliberately: read along, the \"§ 2\" inside it would\n become the target and the wrong norm would be amended.\n\n * C0 control characters are now stripped. Berlin\u0027s enumeration indent\n carries a U+0007 that sits invisibly in front of the command and made\n its start-of-line anchor miss.\n\n * Command verbs torn apart by a stray space in the official typesetting\n (\"ein gefügt\" for \"eingefügt\") are rejoined, restricted to sequences\n that are not valid German word order.\n\nThree of Article 1\u0027s four commands are now recognised. The fourth places\nthe new unit by a word anchor (\"Vor den Wörtern … wird folgender Absatz 5\neingefügt\"), which StrukturEinfuegung cannot express; that and the\ninability of the plain-text stem format to carry an Anlage at all are\nrecorded in Landesrecht-Beispiele.adoc.\n\n231 tests green; all pinned figures unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: Ic5804bf343dd5d8ce435c07b8f882ca0372890d2\n" }, { "commit": "c86a73a6e1da7dd28076054936458b850eda2947", "tree": "179aa5b90857750bbaf41b20a401985206b6817f", "parents": [ "83ba9f0db3462a4c2d5122ba836f646b055156ca" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 08:02:10 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 26 08:02:10 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Berlin column spike: stream order already reads correctly\n\nThe plan assumed the two-column Berlin gazette would need x-coordinate\ncolumn detection. It does not: the content stream already emits the left\ncolumn fully before the right one, so commands come out in reading order.\nThe test pins that finding.\n\nWhat does go wrong there is different, and two parts of it are fixed:\n\n * The article\u0027s amendment formula carries its own target (\"§ 2 Satz 1\n des Gesetzes zur Errichtung … wird wie folgt geändert\"), but the\n following items never inherited it. The pattern\u0027s leading \\b could\n never match before \"§\" — a non-word character needs a word character\n in front of it — so the paragraph branch was dead code and only the\n Bavarian \"Art.\" branch ever fired.\n\n * The running page header is not a line of its own; it sits inside the\n body text of the following column, so it has to be cut out rather\n than dropped as a column title.\n\nTwo blockers remain and are recorded rather than papered over: Article 1\namends an *Anlage* with its own numbering, which the model does not carry\n(the same gap that shelved Baden-Württemberg), and full-width frames\n(title block, imprint) sit elsewhere in the stream than on the page,\nwhich would need a real XY-cut. Stems are unobtainable either way —\ngesetze.berlin.de is an authenticated juris app like the Schleswig-\nHolstein portal.\n\n229 tests green; all pinned figures unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I4619dbe96a023d61104d7107a9a34533123d1bc5\n" }, { "commit": "83ba9f0db3462a4c2d5122ba836f646b055156ca", "tree": "82b786836898972cf1291f2b8739098f762e3baf", "parents": [ "35e90f4ab0f9b40d4752c9b8cba57c9452a8189f" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 10:35:45 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 10:35:45 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Support the two Lower Saxony insertion forms; NEFG now applies fully\n\nThe NEFG acceptance case left two commands as \"check manually\". Both are\nnow supported, so Lower Saxony applies 7 of 7 with no remainder.\n\n * Lower Saxony cites inserted paragraphs with a space before the sub\n number (\"§ 2 a\"); the rest of German legal usage writes \"§ 2a\", which\n is what the Stelle and level parsers expect. TextBereiniger now pulls\n the form together, leaving enumeration markers of the amendment act\n alone (\"… nach § 8 c) In Absatz 2 …\").\n\n * \"In Kapitel 4 wird nach § 12 der folgende neue § 13 angefügt\" — the\n division only names the section the new paragraph lands in; the\n anchor governs the position, as in the plain form. The optional\n \"neue\" is now accepted in both.\n\nApplying that insertion needed one more thing: the paragraph it creates\nis only vacated by the *following* command (\"Der bisherige § 13 wird\n§ 14\"), so in document order the two collided and the insertion was\nrejected. \"Bisherig\" denotes the state before the amendment, so the\nrenumbering logically precedes the reoccupation and is now pulled ahead.\nThe log still lists commands in the order of the amendment act.\n\n226 tests green; all other pinned figures unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I0e2ea5b0389f8002157eeb8471800da51febe739\n" }, { "commit": "35e90f4ab0f9b40d4752c9b8cba57c9452a8189f", "tree": "271b8ce1f0537bc8546e3939d99df6e47d79369b", "parents": [ "519c1e7b769c37769d1b5d1ffd6e13566b26c86d" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 10:00:36 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 10:00:36 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Add North Rhine-Westphalia TMZ-Gesetz acceptance case\n\nArticle 3 of the 22. Rundfunkänderungsgesetz (GV. NRW. 2026 S. 202) amends\nthe Telemedienzuständigkeitsgesetz. All four commands apply cleanly, and\nthe result matches the official consolidated version of 1 April 2026.\n\nrecht.nrw.de turned out to be the one remaining state portal that serves\nconsolidated laws as server-rendered HTML, with the version history\nencoded in the URL date prefix — so the pre-amendment stem (27 Apr 2022)\nwas directly obtainable.\n\nTwo fixes were needed:\n\n * LandesRechtTextParser read the parenthesised title suffix wholly as\n the abbreviation. State laws routinely carry both short title and\n abbreviation there (\"(Telemedienzuständigkeitsgesetz – TMZ-Gesetz)\"),\n and the amendment act cites the short title, so article selection\n never matched. The parser now splits at the dash.\n\n * ZitatExtraktor swallowed the rest of the document when a closing\n quotation mark is missing in the official text (Article 2 no. 11\n here), which hid Articles 3 to 5 entirely. An amendment act never\n quotes across an article heading, so an open quotation is now closed\n before a bare \"Artikel N\" line, with a warning. Quoted paragraphs are\n unaffected: Bavarian norm heads read \"Art. N\".\n\n223 tests green; all previously pinned figures unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I78470075d9be2433966b821b6fe1e21808996c46\n" }, { "commit": "519c1e7b769c37769d1b5d1ffd6e13566b26c86d", "tree": "59c8deaa1e34c3464801e9337fc2a92a15af307d", "parents": [ "43e91612875de3cc6e7466eee56023ab55cefd89" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 09:11:56 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sat Jul 25 09:11:56 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Add Schleswig-Holstein extraction case and three cleanup fixes\n\nThe GVOBl. Schl.-H. amendment act (Kommunalrecht, 2026/27) brings three\nconventions the tool had not seen:\n\n * a running two-line page header that sits between articles and glued\n itself onto the following article heading,\n * superscript footnote markers on article headings (\"Artikel 1 ¹)\"),\n which defeated the article split, and\n * ragged-right typesetting, where the geometric margin detection finds\n no alignment cluster and reports full lines as hard line ends, so a\n trailing hyphen was never joined.\n\nAll three are fixed in TextBereiniger; the hyphen rule now trusts the\nextractor\u0027s trailing-space signal over the geometric class.\n\nA full acceptance test is not possible: the Schleswig-Holstein law portal\nserves document bodies only through an authenticated API, and the last\nfreely archived consolidated Gemeindeordnung (14 Nov 2022) predates the\namended § 34a. The new test therefore covers everything up to and\nincluding command recognition; the blocker is recorded in\nLandesrecht-Beispiele.adoc.\n\n219 tests green; Bund/Bayern/Sachsen/Niedersachsen figures unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I9b3ab8a756372504b51c4d410b491fded255da96\n" }, { "commit": "43e91612875de3cc6e7466eee56023ab55cefd89", "tree": "867f602cd8b00a320987cde8947778deaa7efa45", "parents": [ "3f81addcfbeae7aabcdd823340397f66e394f02f" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Fri Jul 24 22:29:35 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Fri Jul 24 22:29:35 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Add Lower Saxony NEFG acceptance case and two parser robustness fixes\n\nSecond §-structured Landesrecht case for wave six: the Lower Saxony ELER Support\nAct (NEFG, unchanged since 2022, derived from the two-column Nds. GVBl 2022 No. 33)\nplus the amending act of 28 Jan 2026 (Nds. GVBl 2026 No. 10). Five of seven\ncommands apply — both \"erhält folgende Fassung\" re-enactments (§ 1(1), § 2), the\ncitation replacement in § 1(5), the words insertion in § 6(1), and the § 13 → § 14\nrenumbering.\n\n- LandesRechtTextParser: a norm head no longer accepts a title ending in a full\n stop, so a cross-reference sentence at line start (\"§ 7 GAPInVeKoSG findet\n entsprechend Anwendung.\") is not misread as a norm head \"§ 7\" (which had made the\n monotonicity check swallow the norms in between).\n- TextBereiniger: strip the Lower Saxony GVBl running footer and publisher line.\n The footer sat between two enumerated items and otherwise attached to the\n preceding re-enactment quote, defeating its end-of-sentence anchor.\n- Add sampledata/Niedersachsen/NEFG-alt.txt and EndToEndTest.nefgAcceptance.\n\nTwo insertion forms remain documented residues (manuell prüfen): inserting a\n§-block with a space-separated sub-number (\"§ 2 a\") and a chapter-scoped §-block\ninsertion (\"In Kapitel 4 wird nach § 12 … angefügt\").\n\n221 tests green; federal, Bavarian and Saxon pinned numbers unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: Ie23eee1f596ec8eecc6a73f6ce585a22e73ec6c9\n" }, { "commit": "3f81addcfbeae7aabcdd823340397f66e394f02f", "tree": "cfc08069f1da4bff2c8f1b67de85e70defad2fa2", "parents": [ "c2b57decf3d57d4808dd37723c562b8e001cc342" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Fri Jul 24 05:34:32 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Fri Jul 24 05:34:32 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Add Saxony SächsBeamtVG acceptance case (first non-Bavarian Landesrecht)\n\nComplete the first §-structured Landesrecht acceptance case for wave six: the\nSaxon Civil Servants\u0027 Pension Act (SächsBeamtVG) in its 1 Feb 2025 version plus\nthe amending act of 13 April 2026 (SächsGVBl. S. 134). All five commands are\nrecognised and applied without residue — the amount replacements in § 47 and the\nre-enactment of § 80(1) sentence 2.\n\n- LandesRechtTextParser: recognise arabic, keyword-first structural headings\n (\"Abschnitt 1\", \"Unterabschnitt 2\", \"Teil 3\") via GLIEDERUNG_ARABISCH, in\n addition to Bavaria\u0027s roman \"I. Abschnitt\" form. Bavaria behaviour unchanged.\n- TextBereiniger: strip the footer of revosax full-text output (REVOSAX_FUSS,\n \"https://…revosax… Fassung vom … Seite N von M\").\n- Add the consolidated pre-amendment stem as canonical plaintext\n (sampledata/Sachsen/SaechsBeamtVG-alt.txt, derived from the archived revosax\n full text) and EndToEndTest.saechsBeamtVgAcceptance (5 applied, 0 manual).\n\n220 tests green; federal and Bavarian pinned numbers unchanged.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I8e878bc9506f24028cf643a873de000f3d066d64\n" }, { "commit": "ab7ac577eedaffabf087a84786bebe9a8904c365", "tree": "0efb32b59b2cf6470e1d09c748ce32ff1698c79a", "parents": [ "65eff08b32a0f00ff0f5e4bda3fe5793f631ed64" ], "author": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 19 09:25:55 2026 +0200" }, "committer": { "name": "Matthias Andreas Benkard", "email": "code@mail.matthias.benkard.de", "time": "Sun Jul 19 09:25:55 2026 +0200" }, "message": "Add Landesrecht amendment samples from eight further Länder\n\nCollect real amendment gazettes/ordinances from Berlin, Schleswig-Holstein,\nHessen, Niedersachsen (two hefts), Baden-Württemberg, Nordrhein-Westfalen,\nSachsen and Thüringen as candidates for a further enhancement wave, plus an\n.adoc overview. Unlike Bavaria (Art./§ inversion) these Länder use § in their\nstem laws; the new test dimensions are PDF layout (Berlin two-column, Hessen\nletter-spacing) and command idioms (\"erhält folgende Fassung\", superscript\nArtikel footnote markers, amtliche Satznummern in a § context). Only the\namendment documents are included so far; the consolidated stem versions and\nRheinland-Pfalz remain open.\n\nCo-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 \u003cnoreply@anthropic.com\u003e\nChange-Id: I0e3e761763038abda144266381cf59f8d8f3bf78\n" } ] }